Building the case for how investments that increase sustainability and resident stability create financial value for property owners and investors.
One of my favorite things to do after a long day of writing emails, reading reports and poring over spreadsheets is to sit down with my wife and watch a good, mindless TV show. Lately, we have been diving into the world of crime procedurals. My personal favorite is Castle, where the New York Police Department, for some reason, lets a witty crime novelist tag along with a detective to solve murders.
Crime procedurals all follow the same structure. The settings and characters change, but there is always murder at the beginning and a resolution at the end. The case always gets closed.
If you watch enough of them (and I very clearly have) some consistent patterns appear that generally point to three different outcomes.
- The Scooby-Doo Solution. This is the one where the killer is the first person you meet. A body is found in an apartment building, the police show up. The landlord shows them around, and by the end of the episode, the landlord ends up being the killer.
- The Most Famous Guest Star Gambit. Simply put, if there is a famous guest star on the show, the odds are pretty good that they will end up being the killer. Solving it takes a decent knowledge of pop culture and quick access to the internet.
- The Most Implausible Scenario. This is where the villain ends up not being the landlord or the guy played by Tony Danza, but rather someone that you would never expect. Someone like the victim's sister, because there was a trust fund, or one of them was adopted, or because she just could not let go of the fact that her little brother always got the white meat at Thanksgiving.
Ever since I was a kid, I have loved finding the pattern underneath things. Because even though the world around us might seem infinitely complex, there are always patterns to be found that point to a finite number of outcomes. We win. We lose. We fall in love. We fall out of love. We keep making the same mistakes. We eventually close the case. The Fibonacci sequence never changes.
The secret to finding these patterns lies in our ability to identify which actions or inputs are likely to lead to the most predictable outcome. It sounds a lot more complicated than it is. Sometimes it is as simple as not having that third glass of wine or knowing that if Daniel Day-Lewis is guest starring on Law and Order, there is a very good chance that his character is the guy who did it.

So why does this matter for affordable housing?
Every Property Is a Case
Last week, I spoke on a panel about the Multifamily Impact Council's research to quantify how resident services and other impact-driven practices can improve a property’s financial performance.
What we are finding is that, not unlike an episode of Castle, every property is a case that can be solved by understanding how a specific resident service practice can be connected to a specific property performance metric. And when we are successful, we can quantify the extent to which an impact-driven practice that improves the financial health and stability of a renter can also improve the financial health and stability of the building in which they live.
The challenge is figuring out how to connect those dots with maximum specificity and minimal assumptions because there are a wide number of reasons why one property might financially outperform a similar property, and the presence of resident services is just one potential factor. And to maintain the credibility of the work we do, we must become more specific in our approach. Because property owners and investors are not interested in simply knowing that the presence of resident services at a property makes it more likely to support net operating income. They want to know the specific types of resident services that drive property performance and how each one achieves success.
And this is what makes the Return on Sustainable Investment (ROSI) methodology so important to the work that we do.
Designed by the NYU Stern School’s Center for Sustainable Business (CSB), the ROSI methodology was developed to help companies put a dollar value on investments in sustainability and social impact. Their approach is already being utilized by global leaders like REI, Eileen Fisher, Owens Corning and Anheuser-Busch, to quantify the financial value of impact investments in the healthcare, apparel, agriculture and energy sectors.
And we figured if this methodology could help identify the patterns of value creation in these industries, then it could probably do the same for apartment buildings. So, in early 2025, the Multifamily Impact Council, with generous support from the Ballmer Group, began working with the NYU CSB team to understand how the ROSI methodology can build off of the industry standard principles in the Multifamily Impact Framework to quantify how services that improve sustainability and resident stability create financial value for property owners and investors.
Following the Evidence
So far, the research with CSB has looked at impact practices from six MIC member companies1 aligned with the Multifamily Impact Framework principles. The main finding is that affordable and moderate-income housing is a resilient asset class and that owners can grow net operating income (NOI) further by adding resident services on top of existing affordability. CSB also found that stacking imapct practices across the Framework principles can deliver more value than focusing on any single one. The pattern is consistent. Specific practices produce specific resident outcomes, and those outcome can help move a specific line on the property's financial statement.
- Housing support plans. When residents eligible for Section 8 assistance fell behind on rent, Mercy Housing offered them a structured plan to get back on track instead of moving to eviction. As a result, more residents stayed housed. The properties kept receiving housing subsidies, avoided eviction legal fees, and reduced vacancy loss and turnover costs. Across the properties studied, the results supported an increase of up to 13% of NOI in 2023, and gains of 2% to 4% in 2024.
- Rent splitting. In some properties, residents who could pay rent in two installments, matching how most people are paid, stayed 2.9 months longer than residents who did not. Longer stays mean higher rental income, lower bad debt and less frequent turnover costs.
- Telehealth. Residents who used free telehealth services stayed 3.59 months longer than nonusers. That translates into lower turnover, vacancy and marketing costs worth about $290 per resident every four years.
- Property Safety. Across 46 properties, a stronger sense of safety inside the building was associated with a 3.09% improvement in occupancy and a 5% improvement in rent realization.
- Solar Power. Cost savings from investments in solar power retrofits pay for themselves in five years with public incentives and in about ten years without public support.
It is important to note that none of these findings prove that one practice alone drives the financial performance of the whole property. That would be the Scooby-Doo Solution, pinning the case on the first suspect we meet. And it is far too simplistic to say that just having resident services at a property will inevitably boost NOI. Anyone who has ever owned, invested in or underwritten a property knows there are other multiple factors involved (including inflation, insurance costs and how a property's debt is structured) that are often outside of anyone's control.
What they do demonstrate, however, is that when property owners invest in practices that improve sustainability and resident stability, they gain more control over the financial performance of their portfolio and increase the likelihood that they will meet their fiduciary obligations.
Why The Methodology Matters
This is where the method matters as much as the findings. Crime procedurals are called procedurals for a reason. Detectives do not close a case on a hunch. They follow the same procedure every time, and that is why ultimately, their answer holds up. Research on resident services works the same way. One study at one property is a good story. The same methodology applied across many properties and many owners produces something owners, investors and lenders can actually underwrite.
That is the value of pairing ROSI with the Multifamily Impact Framework2. When every case is measured the same way, the results can be compared, repeated and trusted. The more cases that are measured, the clearer the patterns become.
Most property owners do not have the time or budget to commission their own study. With credible research built on a common methodology, our goal is to make sure they do not need to3. They can see which practices improve sustainability and resident stability, which ones strengthen NOI, and how the two connect. The factors that make the work of affordable housing hard are not infinite. And because they are not, they can be counted and measured and applied.
And that is not a mystery. It is just a solid real estate practice.
Footnotes:
1 The six MIC member companies are Avanath, Jonathan Rose Companies, Nuveen, Mercy Housing, FCP (Federal Capital Partners), and Comunidad Partners.
2 You can learn more about the MIC's work to support the development of a real estate specific ROSI methodology with NYU CSB here.
3 To read our current research reports and stay up to date with new case studies, please visit our research library.