Nonpayment and Eviction in the Rental Housing Market

New research on 6,000 tenancies shows why landlords evict, and why rental assistance beats eviction filings for landlords and tenants alike.

Nonpayment and Eviction in the Rental Housing Market

This Becker Friedman Institute for Economics working paper from the University of Chicago uses lease-level ledger data on nearly 6,000 tenancies in low-income Midwestern rental markets (2015 to 2019) to explain why landlords evict and whether common tenant-protection policies prevent evictions. It is the first study to link detailed rent payment histories to landlords' eviction decisions.

Specifically, the researchers found that:

  • Nonpayment is common and often tolerated: half of tenants defaulted at least once, landlords typically forbore two to three months of missed rent before filing, and 39 percent of first-time defaulters eventually repaid in full.
  • Unsubsidized tenants paid only 86 percent of rent due, and 38 percent of landlord losses came from tenants who were never evicted.
  • Filing an eviction costs landlords 2 to 3 months of rent plus about two months of vacancy, so most evictions involve tenants unlikely to pay going forward; 85 percent would have missed at least 3 of the next 12 months.
  • A $250 filing tax, a five-week court delay, or short-term rental assistance each cut evictions by about 5 percent, mostly by delaying them. Filing fees and rental assistance were more likely than delays to protect tenants who would resume paying; only rental assistance left landlords better off.

Methodology and Context

The authors estimate a dynamic model in which landlords learn about tenant payment risk over time and weigh eviction costs against the chance of recovery. The findings speak to the housing stability principle of the Multifamily Impact Framework and to MIC's housing support plan research: since forbearance is already widespread and nonpayment losses are large, structured repayment plans and targeted assistance offer owners a financially grounded alternative to eviction.