This brief from the Terner Center for Housing Innovation at UC Berkeley examines how California's Property Tax Welfare Exemption can support construction and preservation of housing affordable at or below 80 percent of Area Median Income without relying on oversubscribed subsidies such as LIHTC or HOME. Drawing on interviews with two dozen developers and finance professionals, the authors document how the exemption works, where it is being used, and what limits wider adoption.
Specifically, the Terner Center found that:
- Property taxes can represent roughly 18 percent of an affordable property's operating budget, and one Bay Area development expects to save about $1 million a year through the exemption.
- Public agencies now supply the nominal government financing needed to qualify: the California Municipal Finance Authority (17 projects, 1,800 units), the Bay Area Housing Finance Authority (7 projects, 789 units), and the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles (two acquisitions, more than 950 units).
- Preservation deals are complicated by unknown tenant incomes at acquisition, slow income verification, loss of the exemption when a household exceeds 100 percent of AMI, and approval timelines of 18 months or more.
Recommendations and Context
The brief recommends faster, more uniform assessor processing; public-benefit guardrails such as BAHFA's 10 percent discount to market and capped rent increases; eligibility for SB 423 and density bonus infill projects; a larger role for regional finance agencies; income self-certification; and incentives for catalytic capital. Programs in Washington, New York, and Oregon are reviewed for comparison. For impact-focused owners, the exemption offers a path to deed-restricted affordability that strengthens operating performance while advancing the affordability and preservation principles of the Multifamily Impact Framework.